Chile taps China and Japan in lithium-for-tech push but faces tough sell
The South American country, the world’s No. 2 lithium producer, has held global road shows ahead of a second lithium-for-investment tender, according to officials and Chilean government documents.
These have attracted dozens of firms in China as well as Japanese battery makers like Toshiba Corp. and Russia’s state nuclear agency Rosatom, the documents show, lured by potential access to Chile’s huge deposits of the “white gold” under the arid salt flats in the Atacama desert.
An auction slated for early 2020 offers a guaranteed supply of discounted Chilean lithium in exchange for a commitment to build battery parts plants in Chile, as the government looks to move up the value chain.
Oversupply and plummeting lithium prices, however, have made the deal a tough sell. In a previous tender in 2018, all three winners — including electronics giant Samsung SDI and South Korean steel mill Posco — subsequently dropped out.
“I don’t see this ending any better than the previous auction,” said Jaime Alee, a Chilean lithium consultant who has advised foreign investors in the country. He noted that the global trend was for supply chains closer to home.
“Given this, I just don’t see the logic in installing (a plant) in Chile,” Alee said.
Nonetheless, Chile’s huge deposits are a lure amid a sharpening race to lock in supplies, which will be key to a future of electrified transport and smart devices.
Chile’s investment and development agencies InvestChile and CORFO held events in China, France, Japan and South Korea this year to drum up interest. They say issues from the first auction have since been resolved.
The road shows attracted interest in China from dozens of organizations, including China Development Bank, energy firm TBEA, chemicals giant Sinochem and aluminum producer Chinalco, documents show.
Japanese banks and miners, South Korea’s overseas infrastructure body, Belgium’s Umicore and French transportation conglomerate Bollore attended other global shows, an official for InvestChile confirmed.
A statement from Rosatom Group confirmed its companies are weighing their options in Chile.
“Rosatom’s organizations are still considering Chile as a potential partner for implementation of lithium projects and supporting local government’s initiatives aimed to attract foreign companies to participate in joint projects in this area,” it said.
Bollore declined to comment, as did Toshiba, with spokesman Ryoji Shinohara adding that “we are not disclosing business-related information, including participation in such road shows, unless an official decision is made.”
Sinochem said in an emailed response it does “not have a plan to build a plant in Chile in the near future.”
A Chinalco spokesman said he was unaware of the matter, while China Development Bank, TBEA and Umicore did not respond to requests for comment.
Chinese interest in Chilean lithium in particular has grown as the Asian giant ramps up production of electric vehicles. Last year, China’s Tianqi clinched a $4 billion deal to purchase a quarter stake in top Chilean lithium miner SQM.
Chile is home to half of the world’s lithium reserves, with both SQM and U.S-based Albemarle — the world’s top producer — extracting the coveted metal from bright blue brine pools on the desert’s vast white salt flats.
However, an investigation in July found that Chile had struggled to capitalize fully on the tenders, failing to make clear both how much lithium it could provide as well as how deeply it would be discounted.
Chilean producers currently export mostly unrefined lithium, not the higher-value battery parts Chile hopes will someday generate added earnings for its export-oriented economy.
Despite the renewed interest, the administration of center-right President Sebastian Pinera has tempered expectations for this second round.
Falling lithium prices and Chile’s distance from consumer markets increase costs and make it difficult to entice foreign manufacturers.
Pablo Terrazas, head of the Corfo development agency that oversees the auction, told lawmakers this month that the offered deal was perhaps not as sweet as anticipated.
“If the battery-making companies are not interested … we can’t obligate them to set up in Chile,” he told lawmakers. “This can still succeed or fail.”
Terrazas said he hopes to entice companies that make parts for batteries used in tools, electric scooters and storage devices.
“We started out wanting to sell the most sophisticated batteries to the likes of BMW or Volkswagen. But I think we need to go little by little … and work our way up,” he said.